Cakes, biscuits, bread and fillings
Bakery
In bakery, sugar is structure, browning and shelf life as much as sweetness. A replacement has to carry all four jobs.
The brief
A bakery formula depends on sugar for aeration, tenderness, browning, moisture and shelf life. Removing it changes the bake, not just the taste. Allulose and tagatose brown; erythritol and isomalt add bulk without browning; inulin and polydextrose add body and fibre. This page describes the grade questions behind a reduced-sugar bakery trial: bulk, browning, moisture migration and the bake test.
Matched ingredients
- Allulose — 98.0–102.0% (HPLC-RI)
- Tagatose — 98.0–102.0% (HPLC-RI)
- Erythritol — 99.0–100.5% (HPLC-RI)
- Maltitol — 98.0–101.0% (HPLC-RI)
- Inulin — ≥90.0% (HPLC-RI)
What changes in this format
Three constraints, one grade decision.
The same powder can pass one constraint and fail another. The trial should test all three.
Browning and caramelisation
Allulose, tagatose and maltitol can brown; erythritol and isomalt do not brown like a reducing sugar. The crust colour and the flavour will change, and the bake time may need to be revalidated.
Bulk and aeration
Replacing sugar with a high-intensity sweetener removes the bulk that traps air and holds moisture. A polyol, a fibre or a rare sugar has to fill that role, or the crumb collapses.
Moisture migration
Sorbitol and glycerol are humectants; erythritol and isomalt are not. The same replacement can make one cake dry and another one sticky. Test the crumb and the pack, not only the sweetness.
Ingredients for this application
Starting points, not a shortlist limit.
Every grade is quoted against the specification and the process, not against the application label.
Allulose
C₆H₁₂O₆ · CAS 551-68-8
98.0–102.0% (HPLC-RI)
Tagatose
C₆H₁₂O₆ · CAS 87-81-0
98.0–102.0% (HPLC-RI)
Erythritol
C₄H₁₀O₄ · CAS 149-32-6
99.0–100.5% (HPLC-RI)
Maltitol
C₁₂H₂₄O₁₁ · CAS 585-88-6
98.0–101.0% (HPLC-RI)
Inulin
(C₆H₁₀O₅)n · CAS 9005-80-5
≥90.0% (HPLC-RI)
Polydextrose
Glucose polymer with sorbitol and citric acid · CAS 68424-04-4
≥90.0% (HPLC-RI)
Isomaltulose
C₁₂H₂₂O₁₁ · CAS 13718-94-0
≥98.0% (HPLC-RI)
Crystalline Fructose
C₆H₁₂O₆ · CAS 57-48-7
≥99.5% (HPLC-RI)
Pectin (HM/LM)
Partially methylated polygalacturonic acid · CAS 9000-69-5
≥65.0% (dry basis)
Acacia Gum (Gum Arabic)
Acacia senegal polysaccharide · CAS 9000-01-5
≥85.0% (AOAC 2009.01)
Next step
Describe the finished product. We will name the grade.
The dose, the process step, the taste and the destination are enough to start a specification review.